|
Written
by David Tischman, Illustrated by Igor Kordey.
Issues 97 - 100 (one story) of Cable collected into one Trade
Paperback.
This
4 part tale collected into one book is from the latter issues
of the ongoing Cable series (before it was rebooted & renamed
"Soldier X"). Cable (Nathan Summers or "Nate")
is a character that began as a flat, stereotypical character but
over the years (mainly due to the efforts of writer Fabian Nicieza
in the pages of X-Force and the X-Men titles, as well as in Cable's
own comics) he has become an interesting character with the potential
for great stories. The Shining Path tells of Cable's trip to Peru
to save the troubled country from the ambitions of the terrorist
organisation named "The Shining Path". As he fights
to "save the future by changing the present" he is also
attempting to pass on the teachings of the Askani order (the clan
in the future that raised him... a long and convoluted story)
to the people he runs into.
The concept is an interesting one and could have resulted in a
very good story. Instead it just misses the boat, though it's
not without redeeming qualities. David Tischman's writing is rather
average, solid but lacking in any kind of flare. His thought boxes
(for want of a better term) are very basic and adequate at best.
His dialogue is of a slightly higher quality though some of it
is really cold and emotionless. In particular he writes a very
icy and personality-free Cable. Whilst I am unaware of what the
character has been through since the first 35 issues I read, I
do assume he hasn't been completely destroyed as a human being.
The dialogue is mostly functional, perhaps displaying an inexperience
in writing this kind of book from Tischman. The plotting is also
solid but distinctly lacking in any vibrancy or energy. It's predictable
in the way it deals with the whole "terrorists/freedom fighters
taking over a country" issue and the story rumbles along
without trying to really engage the reader. You want to read on
but only just. The rather ropey art doesn't help matters either.
Ropey art? Perhaps. There's a certain style to it and I can't
deny that at times during the book I felt a great appreciation
of Igor Kordey's work. However there are too many instances when
the characters reach new levels of deformity and messiness. The
inking (Kordey's own) is far too harsh and "slap it all on".
A better inker, such as Dan Green, Tim Townsend or Art Thibert,
could have brought his pencils to life in a way that his own flat
and overly-simplistic inking cannot. His depiction of Nathan is
often overly skinny & short (yes, Cable's size seems to change
from panel to panel), which isn't what I'm used to for the character.
He also inflicts some truly awful work on Nate's hair throughout
the book. Still, bonus points for managing to keep the one artist
for all 4 issues collected here. Marvel's notorious ability to
have to intersperse fill-in pencillers every 2 or 3 issues had
reached new heights when last I read regularly from their output.
Visual consistency is important when telling an enclosed story
like this.
Overall it's a rather average book. The major revelation for Cable
during this story arc is something that should be a really momentous
event in his life. Instead it comes across as something that just
kind of happens and which he treats in the same cold fashion with
which he is written throughout the book. His powers are treated
in a nice manner though. Cable's use of telekinetic shielding
and small, precise shots of telekinetic & telepathic power
suit the setting and task he is engaged in. Perhaps the most interesting
part of the tale for me was the introduction of Askani teachings
to the small children of the revolutionary camp, who then proceed
to prevent the adult fighters returning and continuing to ruin
their lives. I would have liked to see more of the teachings being
discussed by the kids and spread amongst them. If that had got
more focus then the book would be all the better for it. However,
as it is "Cable: The Shining Path" is a rather average
collection that could have been something more. Unless you're
a completist then it's a little hard to recommend parting with
the cash for this one. It's certainly unlikely to excite new readers
and as an old reader returning to see where the comic had got
up to, I would rather have come in someplace else.
Written to - Settle For Nothing
|